Days after FIFA secretary general Jérôme Valcke called the fight “nonsense,” the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario stated that soccer’s world governing body had in fact been properly served papers requesting their response to a discrimination claim.
On Monday, HRTO adjudicator Jo-Anne Pickel wrote “that FIFA has received effective legal notice” of players’ complaints regarding turf. FIFA argued that legal action must comply with the Hague Service Convention, a notion that Pickel rejected. Pickel also on Monday rejected players’ appeal to have the case expedited.
A group of international players – who lawyers say exceed 80 in number – took legal action against FIFA and the Canadian Soccer Association on Oct. 1 for their plans to use “inferior” artificial turf at the 2015 Women’s World Cup. Every men’s World Cup has been played on natural grass.
On Friday Valcke went on the defensive at the press conference before Saturday’s Women’s World Cup Draw.
MORE: Complete coverage of the 2015 Women’s World Cup Turf War]
“If anyone is saying that the use of the artificial pitch is a question of discrimination, it’s nonsense.” He said. “It has nothing to do with discrimination.” Valcke also said that comparing the $15 million prize money for the Women’s World Cup to the $576 million men’s World Cup prize money is “nonsense.”
According to Pickel in her ruling — which can be read in full here — Valcke “acknowledged receipt of the materials by facsimile” on Oct. 3, but refused acceptance of the notice and documents on the basis that it was not delivered in compliance with international treaties.
“FIFA’s effort to evade the jurisdiction of the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal has failed,” players’ coalition attorney Hampton Dellinger said in a statement. “[Monday]’s decision makes it clear that FIFA’s legal gamesmanship has proved a loser.”
Dellinger disputed Valcke’s proclamation that he will have an “open dialogue” with players, saying that Valcke would not agree to a conference call last week with players who could not be in Ottawa for the World Cup Draw due to playing commitments.
Valcke said that he would not speak with lawyers and he would not speak to players on the phone. Valcke welcomed the idea of meeting at the FIFA Ballon d’Or Gala on Jan. 12. Citing Valcke’s quote that he is “ready to travel wherever I have to travel” to speak with players on the issues, Dellinger invited Valcke to fly to Brazil and meet with Abby Wambach and Marta, who are both in Brazil for a tournament.
Valcke said on Friday that he recently flew to Paris to speak with two French players.
On Tuesday Pickel granted players their request to amend their application to include alleged reprisal from FIFA and federations toward players.
Players have asked for a case management conference call to deal with preliminary issues. Pickel wrote in her ruling that “this request will be addressed in due course.”
The Women’s World Cup kicks off on June 6, 2015 – less than six months from now.
Your accountSign in
Analysis/ 1 day ago
The Equalizer Podcast: Challenge Cup; USWNT goalkeepers
Access the best women’s soccer coverage all year long Start your FREE, 7-day trial...
NWSL/ 2 days ago
Lauren Barnes: Approaching 200 games and the NWSL’s growth
Saturday, nearly 40,000 fans will be filling Lumen Stadium in Seattle for the Seattle/Portland...
NWSL/ 2 days ago
Bay FC unveils itself with a play toward soccer, timelessness and, yes, merchandise
The 2024 NWSL expansion team in the San Francisco Bay Area will be known...