Russian Nightmares: Four former WPS players leave clubs abroad following contract disputes

Jeff Kassouf May 2, 2012 13
Leigh Ann Robinson

Leigh Ann Robinson was one of four former WPS players to return home from Russia after unhappiness with her club, Rossiyanka. (Photo © Patricia Giobetti | http://www.printroom.com/pro/psgiobetti)

Russia is a special place.

That is the phrase that resonated around Kia McNeill and Leigh Ann Robinson during their two months with Russian powerhouse club Rossiyanka. The words still echo through their minds when they talk about their recent experiences halfway across the world.

Four former Women’s Professional Soccer (WPS) players ventured to Russia to play this spring, but all four have since returned, citing contract breaches and lack of professionalism.

The pair of former Philadelphia Independence defenders made the decision in mid-February to chase the professional dream and head to Russia for the spring following the unexpected suspension of WPS.

Rossiyanka’s home base of Krasnoarmeysk, 32 miles northeast of Moscow’s center, was not the ideal geographic setting for the Americans. But the appeal of a club working on a multi-million dollar budget with top-notch facilities and government financial backing is something out of a women’s soccer player’s fairytale.

That description is almost too good to be true. For these four former WPS players, it was.

Yael Averbuch joined McNeill and Robinson at Rossiyanka (the same Rossiyanka which decided to have its players wear bikinis during a match last year). Averbuch stayed for only three weeks in late February and early March as the team tried to advance in the UEFA Champions League, currently the most coveted women’s club championship in the world. Averbuch has  been capped 16 times by the U.S. but is not in the picture for the Olympics.

Jamaican international and former magicJack midfielder Omolyn Davis, also elected to give the Russian Premier League a try in the absence of WPS. She and former University of Portland star forward Danielle Foxhoven, who had been selected No. 17-overall in the 2012 WPS Draft by the Philadelphia Independence, joined Russia’s other top team, FC Energiya Voronezh.

The Rossiyanka trio of 25-year-olds received word on Wednesday, February 15 that they had to get to an embassy by closing time on Friday to pick up visas that would be waiting. Their flights to Moscow were that Sunday.

Averbuch made the short trip to New York City from her Montclair, N.J., home and McNeill hopped a last-minute flight to the Big Apple from Atlanta. McNeill dropped the graduate course she was taking at St. Joseph’s University in Philadelphia, which was a step toward the business administration master’s program she will begin at Boston College in the fall.

Robinson flew from San Diego to San Francisco for her visa, then onto New York and Moscow. She walked away from some coaching jobs in Southern California to take the opportunity in Russia.

And from the moment the three Rossiyanka players arrived, there were problems.

Kia McNeill

Kia McNeill joined Robinson at Rossiyanka for two frustrating months in Russia. (Photo © Patricia Giobetti | http://www.printroom.com/pro/psgiobetti)

“Just from the beginning we were hoping for a little bit better communication,” Robinson said.

The apartment that Robinson, McNeill and Averbuch were supposed to move into was still occupied by a middle-aged male from Washington, D.C., but a club administrator ensured them that it was safe, McNeill said. McNeill’s protest got the three Americans a hotel room, but that option proved equally alarming.

“Even our coach said he would never step foot in the hotel they put us in,” McNeill said. “I think if our owner knew we were in that hotel, he would have been really upset.”

The three players spent much of their first month with the team on the road, traveling to Spain and France for friendlies before a UEFA Champions League match with Potsdam, from Germany’s Frauen-Bundesliga.

Similarly, Davis and Foxhoven were with Energiya Voronezh on an exhibition trip in Turkey, so none of the five players got an immediate feel for life inside Russia.

After Rossiyanka bowed out to Potsdam 5-0 on aggregate in the Champions League quarterfinals, Averbuch headed back to the States. But McNeill and Robinson continued on to Russia, where none of their problems got resolved.

The pair still lived out of hotel rooms and even utilized their coaching staff’s empty house while the staff was away with the Russian national team. But the players weren’t getting paid. On the 10th of April, they still had not received any compensation for March. They also were did not receive guaranteed stipulations of their contract, the pair said. There was no apartment and there weren’t even smaller items that were supposed to be provided, per the contract, like cellphones (the three Americans shared one phone).

Davis had a better initial experience with Voronezh. She was reimbursed for travel expenses nearly upon arrival and she said she was very impressed with the team’s facilities. In Russia, clubs have base camps which serve as something of an all-in-one college campus for soccer players. Voronezh’s camp featured two grass fields and one turf pitch, along with a gym, sauna and professional chefs serving three meals per day, Davis said.

But the 24-year-old Jamaican returned from the Turkey preseason trip to Voronezh – about 320 miles south of Moscow – having to fight for her apartment, which was guaranteed in her contract. There were always empty promises of paychecks coming soon, Davis said.

Nearly two months into their Siberian escapade, enough was enough. The players wanted out. Easier said than done. A chat with head coach Farid Benstiti about their displeasure with the club left Robinson and McNeill alarmed.

“He said, ‘Russia is a special place,’” McNeill said, describing the discussion with Benstiti. “’Maybe we find something wrong with what you did if you find something wrong with us. Maybe the owner doesn’t let you leave.’ Everyone’s answer to everything is, ‘Russia is a special place.’”

The players began to fear for their future, but time was on their side. Their visas expired in mid-April, meaning they had to renew them or leave the country.

“That was our saving grace was that our visa was up,” McNeill said. “I honestly think that was the only way that we got out of there.”

Multiple emails sent to administrators from Rossiyanka and Energiya Voronezh were not returned.

Shek Borkowski, current coach of WPSL Elite League’s FC Indiana, coached Zvezda-2005 during the 2009-10 Russian Premier League season. He said he never had any problems with getting paid while he was there, but he suggested that players never opt out of their contracts.

“That’s a typical strategy over there,” Borkowski said. “When they want to get rid of a player there they will make it very uncomfortable for a player. But if you are a player, never [opt out]. The club has to pay you if they want to get rid of you.”

That was his advice to Davis, who contemplated her options with Energiya.

Omolyn Davis is still owed money by FC Energiya Voronezh. (Photo Credit: wpsmagicjack.com)

Davis alerted world player representative organization FIFPro of her problems and had to hire a lawyer – Californian Jeff Benz, who is from Moscow – to get her money. She was with Energiya for exactly two months and has since been paid for one month. She has a contract with Energiya that states the club will pay the remainder of what is owed by July 31.

This was not her first run-in with a volatile club. The former George Mason star spent 2011 with infamous WPS club magicJack, which is still involved in a legal battle with the quickly dying league.

Eventually, all four players got paid, but it was far from the Friday afternoon paycheck from accounting. After threatening to go to FIFA with their story, Robinson and McNeill were reimbursed for their thousands of dollars in expenses – in an envelope with cash.

“Money is no objective over there,” Borkowski said.

Whereas WPS teams focused on balancing tight budgets and cutting expenses, Russian team just…spend. They are regionally financed by political backers, although where the money is allocated varies each year, Borkowski said. In 2009, Borkowski’s Zvezda team had a €3 million budget. Rossiyanka had a €9 million budget, he said.

But money does not equate to happiness. Nor does it breed professionalism, McNeill said.

“It’s a bit ironic in some ways,” she said of Russia’s lavish women’s soccer spending. “It’s crazy to see that this club has so much money and they are not professional in any sense of the word. Then this league in the U.S. [WPS], you have these girls who are passionate. You have everything going for it but they have no money.”

Averbuch, McNeill and Robinson admit they were brought in at a time of change – turmoil, even – at the club.

Benstiti, former coach of European power Olympique Lyon, was hired in January, replacing longtime female Russian coach Tatiana Egorova. Benstiti, who also coaches Russia’s national team, got rid of many Russian players and brought in some international talent – like the three Americans – to boost the squad’s Champions League hopes. Brazilians Cristiane, Fabiana, Ester and young Swedish talent Sofia Jacobssen also play there.

The result was an unhappy core of Russian players, which could explain the harsh welcome. (“We get there and get on the bus and nobody says hello, nobody says welcome and nobody even introduces themselves,” McNeill said. “I thought it must be the community bus, not the team bus.”)

Borkowski, however, noted that Russian players are unlike Americans. They treat the job as exactly that and don’t partake in much of the team bonding that goes on in U.S. women’s sports.

Yael Averbuch returned from her time with Rossiyanka after only three weeks. (Photo © Patricia Giobetti | http://www.printroom.com/pro/psgiobetti)

“It’s not like the United States where you come in with a welcome wagon,” he said. “They show up, they do their job and they leave. They are not the friendliest bunch in that sense.

“If you are a player making $20,000 a month and there is this new guy coming in trying to take your job, you are not going to take them out for ice cream. It’s a job.”

Cultural barriers surely played a role in the stories of these four individuals and their brief ventures into a still largely unknown land for soccer.

But as bad as they say their time was, there were valuable lessons to be learned.

“I think the only bad decision I have made was to not include a return flight in my contract,” Davis said en route home after days of uncertainty as to whether or not she could even exit the country.

And for Averbuch, McNeill and Robinson, it was a potentially once in a lifetime opportunity to experience Champions League soccer.

“To be honest that’s the only reason I don’t regret going,” Averbuch said. “I got to experience Europe and get a taste for things over there.”

Foxhoven remains with Energiya, where she has already scored five goals in just two appearances, including a hat trick against Kubanochka on April 26.

The three Americans are back in the States and Davis is currently in Jamaica. She has to figure out her immediate playing future, which will include either a WPSL Elite League team or  a W-League team.

Averbuch will play with local W-League club New Jersey Wildcats, now under the guidance of Jim Gabarra, former 10-year coach of the Washington Freedom.

McNeill and Robinson – who admitted the experience in Russia made her contemplate walking away from the game altogether – will reunite with Paul Riley in Long Island to play for the New York Fury of the WPSL Elite League. Riley coached the two players with the Philadelphia Independence.

All of those domestic settings will place players in more familiar surroundings, where comfort will make up for the lack of money.

“That was our saving grace was that our visa was up….I honestly think that was the only way that we got out of there.
  • Elizabeth

    Wow. Great work Jeff..this was certainly eye-opening. “Russia is a special country”…how creepy!

    I am glad everyone got out okay. I hope Foxhoven will be alright.

  • Diane

    Hope Dani Foxhoven is having a better time of it than these four. It’s a sad situation, but hopefully enough players have spread the word & others won’t fall prey.

  • Pingback: NASR TODAY – May 2, 2012 | NASR

  • http://foot2day.ru/woman_football Ivan Adamenko

    They do not play football in Russia. Think only about the money!

    • Samson Dingle

      The American players, yes?

  • Pingback: The Philly Soccer Page » Flooding, timidity, money & more morning news.

  • Jason

    That should be “citing” contract breaches.

  • Scott

    Communist suck

  • Joshua

    “Russia is a special country”. It certainly seems that way.

    Marta was quoted somewhere in the Swedish media a few weeks ago as saying she was offered more money to play in Russia than Sweden, but she opted to return to Sweden. Now I can see why.

  • Joshua

    “Communist suck”

    Got news for you. The Soviet Union collapsed and the Communist Party was ousted from power over twenty years ago in 1991. Welcome to Putinland.

  • Anders

    I think that women should especially be aware that discriminatory behavior in Russia is very common. I don’t know these athletes, but the pictures show at least two of them to be dark skinned. I suppose if one is a prominent foreigner, a pop star in Moscow or St. Petersburg and black, one might be okay. But not as a black woman player in these smaller cities. It is maybe for the best that they are now safely out of Russia. Going to play in Russia is not like going to play in France, Sweden, Germany, or England. Joshua, it might not be the communism of the USSR prior to 1991, but it is still a nation of many, many totalitarian practices, failed justice system, corruption, and old USSR practitioners. The “party” might have a new veneer, a new name, but it is still a jackboot party. (and there is only one)

  • http://www.funwhileitlasted.net Andy Crossley

    The remarkable thing is that Shannon Boxx was not involved.

    • necron99

      I don’t understand this comment. Is there a joke I missed?